Real estate speculation pushing up prices
By JEANNINE AVERSA, AP
WASHINGTON (AP) - Home builder Marsha Elliott is selling two units in a brand new
stucco and stone duplex. But the buyer isn't planning to move in or rent.
Hoping to capitalize on rapidly rising home prices, the buyer intends to sell the units
shortly after the July closing, Elliott says. It's part of the speculative activity in
the sizzling housing market that is drawing concerns from Federal Reserve Chairman
Alan Greenspan and others.
In Elliott's suburban Chicago development, the buyer locked in a deal months ago
to purchase each unit for $775,000, she says. They are currently selling for
$840,000 apiece, an 8.4 percent jump in price.
Seeking to discourage such activity, Elliott now includes a provision in her
contracts that gives her the option of buying back a property at the original
price if the owner wants to sell within 18 months after closing. Other sellers
are taking similar steps.
"If the buyer doesn't find someone to flip the property to right after closing,
it sits empty. Is it going to be maintained? Is it an open invitation to
vandalism? And, does it have a negative impact on the overall community?
Absolutely," says Elliott, president of Terrestris Development/MLC Homes.
Three percent of home buyers sell in a year or less, according to a
survey by the National Association of Realtors.
While a vacant house can be a turnoff to house hunters, buying and
quickly unloading a house to make a profit can help drive up prices.
Speculative activity, surging home prices and renewed interest in risky
mortgages such as interest-only loans are all byproducts of the booming
housing market.
Greenspan said it appears unlikely that a national housing bubble will
develop and pop, sending prices tumbling. At the same time, he said,
"There do appear to be, at a minimum, signs of froth in some local
markets where home prices seem to have risen to unsustainable levels."
House prices nationwide rose 12.5 percent over the 12 months ending
March 31, according to figures compiled by the Office of Federal
Housing Enterprise Oversight.
During that period, Nevada posted the biggest increase, 31.2 percent.
California ranked second with a gain of 25.4 percent, followed by
Hawaii, with a 24.4 percent increase, the District of Columbia, with a
22.2 percent rise, and Florida, with 21.4 percent.
"Speculative activity may have had a greater role in generating the
recent price increases than it has customarily had in the past,"
Greenspan says. He said a big part of the quickening pace of home
turnover may reflect the purchase of second homes - either for
investment or vacation.
Over the last four months, home builder Mark Livingston, president of
Bridgeport Development Group, has sold 19 brick houses in the Oklahoma
City area to investors, who live in California, Nevada and Israel. The
houses, which range in price from $130,000 to $185,000, are being rented
out by a leasing company, he says.
He also builds in Phoenix, Ariz., where home prices over the course of a
year surged 19.4 percent. "It hasn't happened to us, but I do know instances
where people purchased a home to be built - and before it is built - it is
sold one or two times," Livingston says.
William Friedman, chief executive officer of Tarragon Corp., which builds
condos in urban areas, especially Florida and New Jersey, says builders,
owners and investors can have different takes on the concept of a housing bubble.
"Well, one man's bubbles are another man's champagne," Friedman says. But
he adds: "Price increases that we've seen this year in lots of markets are
clearly unsustainable. I mean, nothing goes up 20 percent a year indefinitely. "
Thomas Lawler, senior vice president for risk policy at Fannie Mae, sees
strong prospects for housing busts in some areas of the country as lenders
have relaxed terms for home loans. "The probability of such an event
occurring has risen sharply in certain parts of the country," he said recently.
David Seiders, chief economist at the National Association of Home Builders,
says major builders worry about the consequences on the market should investors
dump a large number of homes on the market quickly because of "some whiff of
price problems."
To discourage investor buying, some builders are putting in their contracts
a penalty of $50,000 if the home is sold within one year, he says.
For builders, "the question is: Are the sales durable? Will they stay off
the market?" Seiders says.
Livingston, who survived the "nuclear fallout of the housing market" in the
1980s, offers some advice: Builders need to pay careful attention to the market
and home buyers "have to be careful not to get in over their heads."
Increasingly borrowers are stretching to buy pricey homes, a concern to Fed
officials.
In the last six months of 2004, adjustable rate mortgages and interest-only
mortgages together accounted for the majority of new home loans, according
to the Mortgage Bankers Association.
When rates rise, these borrowers will be vulnerable. "There will be an
interest rate shock coming down the line. It may be two or three years
from now. But there's going to be a good percentage of home owners who
will feel it," says David Lereah, chief economist at the National Association
of Realtors.